2008

First Team: Alex Xenidis (Shelton), Adam Carroll (Shelton), Chris Roy (Cheshire), Jonathon Luder (Hand), Dan Jaffe (Hand), Adam Wilkocki (Xavier)

Second Team: Mike Kim (Cheshire), Pat Field (Cheshire), Mike Edelson (Xavier), Jack Scalzo (Xavier), Scott Miller (Amity), Jake Hackett (Hand)

2007

First Team: Evan Kasowitz (Amity), Ryan Saxe (Amity), Matt Somerville (Amity), Randy Johnston (Hand), Jonathan Lauder (Hand), Wes Hansen (Shelton), Joe Visinski (Shelton)

Second Team: Byrce Watkins (Amity), Peter Luft (Cheshire), Brendan O’Connor (Cheshire), Giordano Morichi (Hand), Dan Rabinove (Shelton), Jon Torraco (Shelton), John Rossi (Xavier)

2006

First Team: Brenton Roman (Amity); Matt Somerville (Amity); Steve Visentin (Cheshire); Alex Morgan (Hand); Kevin Lauder (Hand); John Sedlock (Shelton); Tim Zaprzalka (Shelton); Mike Rideout (Cheshire)

Second Team: Evan Kasowitz (Amity); Taylor Lindner (Cheshire); Peter Luft (Cheshire); Jonathan Lauder (Hand); Randy Johnston (Hand); Joey Carroll (Shelton); Wes Hansen (Shelton); Adam Wilkocki (Xavier)

2005
First Team: Kyle Shea (Amity); Brian Sutherland (Cheshire); John Lindner (Cheshire); Kyle Wilson (Hand); Kevin Goncalves (Shelton); Zach Hansen (Shelton); B.J. Smith (Shelton)

Second Team: Brenton Roman (Amity); Jeremy Saxe (Amity); Matt Somerville (Amity); Taylor Lindner (Cheshire); Pat Kelly (Hand); Brad Hausmann (Shelton); Eric Soderstrom (Xavier)

2004
First Team: Anthony Cofrancesco (Amity); John Lindner (Cheshire); Kyle Magoffin (Cheshire); Andrew Kirkeby (Shelton); B.J. Smith (Shelton); John Post (Xavier); Henry Prescott (Xavier)
Second Team: Michael Pugliese (Amity); Jason Jeracka (Cheshire); Brian Sutherland (Cheshire); Kyle Wilson (Hand); Kevin Goncalves (Shelton); Zach Hansen (Shelton); Steve Berry (Xavier)